Definition of False Teacher: One
who presumes to teach in the Name of the Lord when God has not sent
Francis Chan – A Call to Discipleship?
We were informed of Francis Chan by a believer in Christ whose daughter
is acquainted with a young man who attended Chan’s Cornerstone
Church in Simi Valley, California, and Eternity Bible College. Her
daughter was considering going to California, where she would likely
be involved, through the influence of her friend, with these organizations.
Upon investigation and prayerful consideration, we advised against
At FrancisChan.org, one reads of Mr. Chan stepping down as pastor
of Cornerstone Church because he feels a “call from God” to
go elsewhere - he knows not where. Francis Chan is a nice guy - intelligent,
clean-living, moral, friendly, likable, humorous, serious, sincere,
engaging, and popular. But he hasn’t been a called minister of
God all the years he has been at Cornerstone. And he hasn’t been
connected with God to this day, as a true man of God would be.
“And He said unto them, ‘…that which is highly esteemed
among men is abomination in the sight of God’” (Luke 16:15
Francis has only been intellectually educated in men’s theological
institutions (The Master’s College and The Master’s Seminary)
and brought some of man’s doctrines and ways with him.
Despite all the common trappings of men professing to be ministers
of Christ, however, there is a curious difference in this situation
with Mr. Chan, compared to other false teachers. We viewed a video
of Francis discussing what he perceives to be a calling of God: Francis
Chan Is Stepping Out in Faith....
We believe God may be drawing him, placing a search in him for a genuine
walk of faith. While Francis seems to be relating to that call in terms
of places and works, we believe God may be calling him to much more
and better, calling Francis to Himself, to know Him for the first time.
If there is this call, it is not to a specific work, but a general
call to believe and become a disciple of Christ. In such a case, it
is not strange that it is a mystery to Francis for now, because that
is how God works.
Countless thousands of preachers in the world have come in the Name
of Jesus Christ to serve their own desires and imaginations. So has
it been with Francis Chan, but it seems to me that Mr. Chan has had
a seed of reality that has kept and led him to this point – I
could be wrong. We still see in him a degree of lightness and lack
of sobriety concerning the holy things of God; he seems to view Christianity
as a “serious game,” but God can take care of that in His
way, and one way or another, He will.
As sincere as Francis may be (we give him the benefit of doubt), and
as skilled as he has been in all his works as a human being, motivator,
and communicator, he has been unlearned and without the call of God
when it comes to serving the Lord Jesus Christ as a true minister.
That is not to say that he has fallen short according to the light
Still, if you read The
True Marks of a Cult and Diabolical
you will find more than enough to identify Francis Chan as just another
worldly, presumptuous, run-of-the-mill “man of God,” who
thinks to serve God according to the way he has been taught of men
- much like the ambitious Saul of Tarsus, who learned under Gamaliel
and had great zeal, but didn’t have the true knowledge of his
We can’t condemn Chan for that, but he needs to know that he
errs; he has not learned from God and taken on His ways, but from men,
taking on their ways. And what is the nature of those appealing ways?
“Concerning the works of men, by the word of Thy lips I have
kept me from the paths of the destroyer” (Psalms 17:4 KJV).
If people are looking for a social scene of pleasure and “clean” fun
with a godly name tag to soothe the conscience, then they can follow
any of a great multitude of various ministers, but if they want God,
they better head in another direction altogether, which is straight
to the cross. Could it be that Francis Chan is being drawn to the Lord
and out of men’s works? We most certainly hope so.
Many are the false and few the true. What Mr. Chan thinks to have
been of the Spirit of God is nothing more than imagination from his
religious indoctrination and upbringing. And people follow, not because
of the Spirit of God, but because of Mr. Chan’s force of personality,
doctrine, alliances, intellect, and eloquence - in short, carnal gifts.
They are not being drawn to Christ.
At his website, it says: “Because Francis
and Lisa are still unsure what this ‘step of faith’ looks
like for their lives, they obviously aren’t ready to meet with
people with regard to serving together or to make a commitment to
a certain ministry or country.
They will be in prayer for wisdom and direction from the Holy Spirit
and would appreciate your prayers for them as well.
With regard to going
on a prayer walk with he and Lisa to the different cities they
are praying about possibly moving, they plan to go alone
in order to get away quietly to pray. He hopes you understand and
certainly hopes you will continue to pray for them whenever you
think of it.”
Let’s take a Biblical scenario in
the context of the call of God to a specific mission:
Moses is sitting in the wilderness, looking after his flocks, when
he starts feeling a call, maybe from God?
“Sure am getting tired of tending sheep out here. Bored, bored,
bored. I want something fresh, new, challenging…been here long
enough. Time to move on. Hmmm, I think I’m getting a call. Is
that You talking to me, God?”
Moses continues his cogitations. “What am I feeling? Let’s
see, God, is it to India? Libya? Ethiopia? Canaan? Egypt maybe? Should
I start a ministry? Youth outreach? Single moms? City core slums? All
the needs are great! I need to pray. I have to find out where You want
me (or where I want You to want me?). I’m sure that if I pray
hard enough and get enough people to pray for me, I’ll know soon
enough what You are trying to tell me. And if I should want to go in
that direction, I hope my family and the people around me will understand.”
So then where is God? And how hard does He have to “try” to
say something? Does He have a speech impediment? He Who made the mouth
to speak, can’t He speak clearly? He Who made the ear to hear,
can’t He cause one to hear? Must His message evolve over a span
Is that how God communicated with Moses? Is that how He got through
to Abraham, Isaac, Jacob, Jonah, Isaiah, Elijah, Elisha, Jeremiah,
John the Immerser, Jesus, Peter, and Paul? Imagine Paul on the road
to Damascus after falling to the ground and struck blind, pondering
where he should go next. “What am I feeling led to do? Back to
Jerusalem? Corinth? Tarsus? Hmmm, maybe Damascus?”
God speaks to those He calls when He calls, He speaks unequivocally,
and He is well able to make Himself clearly heard. He is not a man,
and He does not do as man does, and He most certainly does
not leave it up to us to determine His will.
“But in going, it happened as [Saul] drew near to Damascus,
even suddenly a light from the heaven shone around him. And he fell
to the earth and heard a voice saying to him, Saul, Saul, why
do you persecute Me? And he said, Who are you, lord? And the Lord said, I
am Jesus Whom you persecute. It is hard for you to kick against the
goads. And trembling and astonished, he said, Lord, what will You have
me to do? And the Lord said to him, Arise and go into the city,
and you shall be told what you must do” (Acts 9:3-6 MKJV).
Many years later (too long for most to wait), when the time for Paul’s
ministry came, God again spoke plainly:
“As they ministered to the Lord and fasted, the Holy Spirit
said, So, then, separate Barnabas and Saul to Me for the work
to which I have called them. Then having fasted and prayed and laid hands on
them, they let them go” (Acts 13:2-3 MKJV).
Here is the point – God does not leave it up to us to
determine His will. As He has commanded us that “our yea be yea and our
nay be nay,” so He does as He expects of us. He most certainly
makes Himself clearly known.
Whenever I spent time cogitating about the will of God in going somewhere
or doing something, it wasn’t because there was a specific call
to a work for me, but because of one of two things:
One, I was seeking to do my own thing, perhaps restless or dissatisfied
with what I was doing or where I was.
Two, He was drawing me to a deeper walk with Him, but not asking me
to do anything.
But when He did want me to go somewhere or do something, He told me
straight out. For example, in the fall of 1977, my wife and I were
talking, when suddenly He told us He was sending us to Israel - just
like that. We hadn’t been talking about going anywhere that I
can recall, but there it was. I wasn’t particularly set on going,
and my wife certainly did not want to go - indeed, she was crying with
reluctance - yet she had a witness from the Spirit that what I had
heard was true.
God didn’t say when we were going, but we were given to know
that, when the time came, He would tell us. Then, in the beginning
of 1979, He said, “Now is the time. Give them notice at work
and sell everything. You are going to Israel.” We weren’t
permitted to tell anyone where we were going. (I see that Francis and
feel they need private time with God to determine His will, something
to which I can relate.)
It took about two months to prepare, and we were on our way. God still
didn’t say why we were going. We assumed it was to live in Israel,
for the rest of our lives perhaps. We found out about six months after
we got there that we assumed wrong.
But He did with us what He had intended (to deliver His Word to Paul
Cohen) and we were on our way back to…where? We were free to
go anywhere, having no ties or obligations, but we knew it was to Canada.
Where in Canada? We knew we would go to Winnipeg, Manitoba, and not
to the city we lived in when we left. We didn’t hear His voice
on these latter matters, we just knew where we were going. There was
no pondering about it.
Where in Winnipeg? Right from the airport, we were led to call former
acquaintances, which were now in a Christian group, called “The
Move,” founded by Sam Fife. We had little idea of what was going
on there, but there we went, and we were received with open arms. And
as we stayed with them, we were given to speak to them about their
Admittedly, often God does not speak very loudly about some things.
We have found ourselves just going and when we got there, we found
that God had brought us. But we were not feeling a call. We could not
say on those occasions, “We feel the call of God,” and
we did not establish the whats or wheres by searching and prayer. When
God did give the call to do something, it was simple enough for any
child to hear and understand.
General calls are different. I have been in the same state as Francis
Chan more than once (three times in nearly 40 years) when it has come
to a general call unto the Lord.
In the video interview, Francis states:
“I’ve been sensing this calling for a while, that the
Lord wants me to do something different…I don’t even know
what it is. My wife and I have been talking about it, wrestling with
it, really for the last couple of years…but a lot over the last
couple of months, and…doing church in a different way, not
necessarily the formal Sunday services, but I don’t know…I’m
just tired of going back and forth…it’s not fair to the
church, it’s not fair to anyone else….
I really think that’s what the Lord is getting me to do…is
to let go, although I really don’t know where I’m going.”
This reminds me of something concerning our father in the faith, as
recorded in Hebrews 11:8, except that Abraham was given a promise,
whereas Francis does
not say he has been
given one; maybe he has.
“It’s really crazy…I just don’t want to be
making a mistake…sometimes in life you think you’re going
towards God’s call, and you think, ‘Maybe I misred it,’ so….
Just kind of trying to keep in step with the Spirit…I’ve
seen His hand in this…there’s peace in me, there’s
peace in my wife, peace in my kids…which is crazy.
And I think I would be hypocritical if I didn’t go…because
I’ve been telling people all along, man, that you just go, you
do, you just take the step of faith, so here I am sensing the call
and if I don’t go, I almost don’t have anything to teach;
I can’t teach with that same integrity because I felt this call,
How true are those words, and noble!
I see that Francis is searching. I wish I could talk to him and Lisa
and help them out of the works of men, but we will see if they are
truly interested in the God of Israel, the Creator, by the cross, which
is the only way to Him. Could it be that Francis is taking up his cross
to follow the Lord? He is leaving much behind.
Francis and Lisa, if you should be brought to our site - Lord willing,
pray, read away, and talk to us. Don’t be disquieted by what
you may perceive as controversial, unacceptable doctrine. You need
to know and receive what is acceptable to God and not man:
Isaiah 55:6-9 MKJV
(6) Seek the LORD while He may be found; call on Him while He is near.
(7) Let the wicked forsake his way, and the unrighteous man his thoughts;
and let him return to the LORD, and He will have mercy on him; and
to our God, for He will abundantly pardon.
(8) For My thoughts are not your thoughts, nor your ways My ways, says
(9) For as the heavens are higher than the earth, so are My ways higher
than your ways, and My thoughts than your thoughts.
Read the documents we suggest, and read at False
There, Lord willing and by His grace, you will learn what is true and
what is false, what is of God and what is of men. May God open
your eyes and bring your souls to peace and fulfillment in the Lord
Jesus Christ. He will remove all those religious things in which men
seek spiritual solace and comfort of the wrong kind.
Let those who seek truth, righteousness, and peace take up the cross
- that fearful thing which men hate, in which alone they will
find true life. The cross of Jesus Christ is the only Way; there is
no other; for only the death
sentence will avail.
Francis Chan has been weighed in the balance of God and found wanting.
According to the measure of the Lord Jesus Christ, Chan has been, and
remains, a carnal minister of the counterfeit church, a blind guide
leading others into the ditch of fruitless religiosity. Whosoever has
ears to hear, let him hear.